Meet Our Team

Our staff that has over 30 years combined experience and the backing of two of Florida’s largest title insurance underwriting companies, Prestige Title of Brevard has the knowledge, experience, and resources to get your real estate transaction closed. So whether you’re a buyer, seller, mortgage broker, lending institution, or real estate professional we want to be your preferred title insurance provider of choice!

Tiffany Fortenberry

Owner / Licensed Title Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
(321) 242-1675 Fax
E-Mail: Tfortenberry@prestigeclosings.com



Tiffany started in the title industry in 1999 for a Title Agency in South Florida. Moving back to Melbourne in 2003 she was able to continue her growth in the Title Insurance industry and had the opportunity to open her own agency in 2007. Tiffany is committed to providing her customers with superior personalized service and takes the time to understand each individuals expectations. Tiffany is very appreciative for her business relationships with so many of the industry professionals in the Brevard County area and is looking forward to growing together for the years to come. In her spare time, Tiffany enjoys shopping and spending time with her husband, two kids, family and friends.

Click here to order services through Tiffany Fortenberry.

Tonya Bader

Co-Owner / Licensed Title Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
(321) 242-1675 Fax
E-Mail: Tbader@prestigeclosings.com



Tonya Bader entered into the title industry back in 2002 where she worked as a pre-processor for a busy South Florida Title Company. It was there that she was able to expand her knowledge in the title industry to help learn the fundamentals of real estate closings. In 2003 Tonya relocated back to Melbourne, FL where she accepted a position working for a local Brevard County title company and was able to advance to become a closing agent. This later helped her when the opportunity to open Prestige Title alongside her sister Tiffany Fortenberry in 2007 came about. Tonya oversees all the employees of the office and enjoys getting to work alongside all of them to help guide each person in the direction to keep the office running smoothly and efficiently. In her spare time Tonya enjoys shopping, traveling and spending time with her husband and two daughters who keep her very busy. “.

Click here to order services through Tonya Bader.

Shawn Fortenberry

Owner / Marketing Director


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 302-0031 Phone
(321) 242-1675 Fax
E-Mail: Tbader@prestigeclosings.com


Cindy Nienajadlo

Licensed Title Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: Cindy@prestigeclosings.com



Cindy Nienajadlo began her career in the title industry in 1995 as a part-time assistant at a branch office for Stewart Title in the Melbourne area. What began as a part-time job to work around her full-time college schedule, soon developed into a prospective career field. Cindy moved on to assume a full-time position with Fidelity National Title while still attending college full-time and eventually earning her Bachelor’s degree in Business Administration at the University of Central Florida. She was awarded the Circle of Excellence award by Fidelity National Title for exemplary customer service and work ethic. She has been a licensed title agent with the state of Florida since 2005 and managed a branch office for four years. Cindy was excited to join the staff of Prestige Title in 2009 as a senior closer bringing with her a wealth of knowledge not only in the title industry, but of the Brevard County area and real estate market. Cindy is a native of Melbourne, Florida and is married with two sons that keep her on her toes. She enjoys outdoor activities, travelling, reading, watching football, and volunteering with the P.E.O. sisterhood.

Click here to order services through Cindy Nienajadlo.

Teresa Roberts

Licensed Title Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: Troberts@prestigeclosings.com



Teresa started her career in the title industry in Orlando, Florida in 1998 all while attending Valencia Community Colledge for Paralegal Studies. It was then that she gained extensive experience in closing residential, commercial and timeshare transactions. She relocated to the beach from Orlando in 2008 with her husband and daughter. In November 2011 Teresa joined the team at Prestige Title of Brevard as a title insurance closing agent. She takes pride in providing superior customer service. In her spare time, she enjoys spending time with her family at the beach.

Click here to order services through Teresa Roberts.

Emily Ferguson

Licensed Title Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: Eferguson@prestigeclosings.com



Emily Ferguson relocated from Indiana to Melbourne, Florida in 2005 where she began her extensive background in the Mortgage Processing and Lending Profession. In 2013, Emily had the opportunity to transition into the Title field with Prestige Title of Brevard, to which she now considers home. She began with the team as a Title Processor and has worked her way up to become a Closing Agent. Emily is always looking forward to cultivating new client relationships while continuing to expand her knowledge within the Title Industry. Emily is dedicated to her work and is proud to be a part of the Prestige Title of Brevard family. In her spare time, Emily enjoys singing, the culinary arts, theme parks, spending time at the beach and being with her family and friends.

Click here to order services through Emily Ferguson.

Tiffany "TJ" Johnson

Licensed Title Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: Tjohnson@prestigeclosings.com



Tiffany "TJ” Johnson was born and raised in beautiful Brevard County. She graduated from Merritt Island High School and has her Associates Degree from Brevard Community College. She began her title career in 2007 as a title examiner coordinator and then went on to process and post close HELOC loans. In 2012 she joined the Prestige Title of Brevard family as a title processor and has since worked her way up to a closing agent position where she handles all of her own customers files. TJ is always a very positive and dedicated person that will go above and beyond for every customer. In her spare time TJ enjoys to travel, cook, and relax on the beach.

Click here to order services through Tiffany "TJ" Johnson.

Whitney Walls

Title Processor


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: Wwalls@prestigeclosings.com



Whitney Walls hails from Round Rock, Texas and moved to Florida in 2006. She began her career in the real estate industry with Prestige Title in 2015 as their Post Closer. Since then, she has excelled and advanced to a title processing position where she works alongside Closing Agent Tiffany “Tj” Johnson as a team to prepare files for closing. In Whitney's spare time, she enjoys spending time with her family and friends, relaxing on the beach, and outdoor activities.

Click here to order services through Whitney Walls.

Jeremy Rannings

Licensed Title Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: JRannings@prestigeclosings.com



Jeremy started in the title industry with us in 2011. Before this, he built homes for Lennar Corporation as a construction manager and also has experience in land surveying. As for Prestige Title, he started from the ground up making cookies and sitting clients for closings. He was promoted and became one of our short sale gurus and is now a licensed title closing agent. He is the definition to how we grow our employees from within. Jeremy’s number one goal within the company is customer satisfaction. He takes pride in being readily available to answer questions whenever needed. In his spare time, he enjoys spending time with his wife and son.

Click here to order services through Jeremy Rannings .

Tina Siau

Title Processor


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: TinaS@prestigeclosings.com



Tina started working for Prestige Title in 2015 as a title processor when she relocated from South Carolina to be closer to her family. She came from a background of banking for eight years before deciding to make a life change by relocating and starting a new career. She is the title processor for both Jeremy Rannings and Emily Ferguson who keep her very busy. Tina states she is happy to be a part of the Prestige Title family and enjoys working with her sisters Tiffany Fortenberry and Tonya Bader. Tina is happy to be a part of the Prestige Title family and enjoys working with her sisters Tiffany Fortenberry and Tonya Bader. Tina loves what she does as a title processor but is also eager to continue to learn more in the title industry. In her spare time, Tina’s hobbies include spending time with her family, reading, and shopping.

Click here to order services through Tina Siau.

Lora Reininger

Office Administrator/Event Coordinator


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: LoraR@prestigeclosings.com



Lora is a native Floridian and has lived in the Melbourne area for most of her life. Lora has attended Eastern Florida State College and is currently seeking to attain a two year Associate Arts degree with hopes to eventually further her education and obtain her Bachelors degree. Lora began her career in the title industry in 2015 when she accepted the position to be the Office Administrator/Professional Assistant at Prestige Title of Brevard. Coming from being a Human Resources Supervisor at a multimillion dollar sales location of JCPenney and a manager of six years for a large hotel, Lora has extensive experience in staffing, recruiting, office management, event planning, and business development programs. Lora enjoys working side by side with management and being able to contribute some of her ideas and knowledge to helping make the workplace better for everyone. In her spare time Lora enjoys baking, attending music concerts, crafts, and spending time with her children.

Click here to order services through Lora Reininger .

Mackenzie “Kenzie” Spitler

Title Processor


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: MSpitler@prestigeclosings.com



Mackenzie Spitler, whom also goes by “Kenzie” relocated to Florida from Ohio in 2001. In 2014 she graduated from Eau Gallie High school and ventured out on her own to figure out what area of work she wanted to get settled in. She worked several jobs before landing a receptionist position with Prestige Title in 2015. Here she became the first impression of the company and learned the title industry from the bottom up. She was later promoted to our post-closing department for several months. Since then, she has been promoted again and currently working as a title processor alongside closing agent Teresa Roberts as a team. Her goal is to continue learning as much as she can in this position to help her later become a licensed closing agent. In her spare time Kenzie loves going to the beach and watching the beauty of sunsets. She also enjoys spending time with her nephew and working out.

Click here to order services through Mackenzie Spitler.

Nina Williams

Title Processor / Closing Agent


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: NWilliams@prestigeclosings.com



Nina Williams is a Florida native, born and raised in Brevard County. She has spent her life surrounded by family members who work in the real estate industry and was excited for the opportunity to join the title industry in 2015 with Prestige Title. Nina currently works as a processor and is working towards her goal to be a licensed title agent with Prestige Title. In this constantly evolving industry she looks forward to each day expanding her knowledge and facing new challenges. In Nina’s spare time she enjoys spending time with her family and soaking in our beautiful Florida sunshine.

Click here to order services through Nina Williams.

Alaura Seidner

Post Closer


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: Aseidner@prestigeclosings.com



As a Florida Native, Alaura was born and raised here in the Sunshine State. She relocated from Homestead, Florida to Brevard County in 1999 to live closer to her grandparents. She joined the Prestige Title family in 2016 as a receptionist and since has worked her way up to our post-closing Department. She handles all of the disbursing of signed paperwork and money to the necessary locations after the closings have taken place. With her hard work ethic and dedication she hopes to gain the knowledge necessary to continue to grow within the company to the end result of being a licensed title closing agent. In her spare time Alaura likes to spend time with her family and paint.

Click here to order services through Alaura Seidner.

Amanda Naber

Receptionist


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 242-7660 Phone
E-Mail: Anaber@prestigeclosings.com



From Cincinnati, to Tennessee, Amanda has slowly made her way down south and now has lived in Melbourne, FL. for the past 4 years. With a Bachelor’s degree in Communication Disorders from the University of Tennessee, Amanda is fairly new to the real estate industry and is eager to embark her new journey. While being the receptionist for Prestige, Amanda is continuously learning from the other knowledgeable staff members to grasp all concepts and expand her knowledge in the hopes of working her way up and becoming a closing agent herself. In her free time, Amanda enjoys spending time with her dog, family and friends, as well as reading and relaxing.

Click here to order services through Amanda Naber.

Monica Zapotockyr

Business Development Director


5120 N Highway US 1
Melbourne, FL 32940
(321) 591-2543 Phone
E-Mail: monicam@prestigeclosings.com