Our Team

Tiffany Fortenberry

Owner / Licensed Title Agent

First Job: Cashier at Winn Dixie
Favorite Movie: We Bought A Zoo
Hobbies: Spending time with my family and being a youth leader at Church of Viera
Pets: Three dogs – Bear, Marley, and Jazz
Favorite Compliment Received: Compliments about my generosity and hospitality
Introvert or an extrovert: Extrovert – I love people 😊
Something I’m proud of: My two daughters and the team at Prestige Title who work hard to help the business run efficiently
Favorite smell: Coffee in the morning!!!
Favorite holiday: Christmas
Favorite music album: I don’t really have a favorite album per se’ but Hillsong United and Elevation Worship are two of my favorite groups
My perfect day: When absolutely nothing goes wrong, and everything falls into place

Shawn Fortenberry

Owner / Marketing Director

First Job: Bagger at Publix
Favorite Movie: The Matrix
Pets: 3 dogs
Hidden talents or hobbies: Drums
Best compliment I’ve ever received: “You are a great dad”.
Introvert or Extrovert: Extrovert
Something I’m proud of: My family (home and work)
Favorite Smell: Sauteed onions and garlics
Favorite Sports Team: Florida State Seminoles
Favorite Holiday: Christmas
Favorite Music Album: Hard to pick one. Beatles white album, Rush Moving pictures, Van Halen 1984, Pantera mouth for war
My Perfect Day: Tropical day with my family in the Cayman Islands

Tonya Bader

Co-Owner / Licensed Title Agent

First Job: Waitress in the dining room at The Fountains of Melbourne which was an assisted living facility
Favorite Movie: So many great classics – Pretty in Pink has been an all-time favorite and behind that falls Remember the Titans
Hobbies: Shopping at Bath and Body Works 😉 and going to concerts. I love a good concert with great company alongside me!
Pets: We have a 500 gallon saltwater tank full of fish!
Favorite received compliment: I am an old soul and I have pretty eyes
Introvert or Extrovert: I like to consider myself in the middle. I have my close circle of friends and family I mainly like to surround myself with, but I also am outgoing in certain environments
Something I’m Proud of: The success of our company Prestige Title and to look at how far it has come with the hard work that was put into it by all.
Favorite Smell: Eucalyptus and Balsam (but not together)
Favorite Sports Team: I only get into college football. It’s great to be a Florida Gator!
Favorite Holiday: Halloween and Christmas are big in our family. I can’t choose between the two
Favorite Music Album: This is too tough to answer. I grew up on all types of genres of music and to this day I listen to it all. I favor listening to country music but there are just so many great albums out there. Good music touches my soul!
My Perfect Day: Might sound cheesy but any day that I get to hang around the people I love whom contribute to laughter, smiling and good times is a great day in my book. We could be sitting around doing nothing or we could be cruising the big ocean.. anywhere we are, it’s a good day when happy memories are being made.

Cindy Nienajadlo

Closing Manager/Licensed Title Agent

First Job: Dunkin Donuts
Favorite Movie: Gone with the Wind
Hidden Talent: I can play piano
Hobbies: I love watching sports live and on TV, I enjoy volunteering w/ the PEO sisterhood (woman empowering women)
Pets: Turtle, a yellow-bellied slider to be exact
Introvert or Extrovert: Introvert
Something I’m proud of: Two things I am most proud of, MY BOYS
Favorite smell: Cinnamon
Favorite Sports Team: Da Bears, Blackhawks, but of course the Florida Gators
Favorite Holiday: Halloween
Favorite Music Album: Led Zeppelin 4
My Perfect Day: Spending time laughing and hanging out with my husband and my two sons – Enjoying some good food helps too!

Jeremy Rannings

Licensed Title Agent

First Job: Kmart – stocking shelves
Favorite Movie: Probably Breakfast Club
Hidden Talent: Drinking beer….It’s not hidden 😊
Pets: One dog, husky, named Kobi
Something I’m proud of: My son
Favorite smell: Peppermint and Eucalyptus
Favorite Sports Team: Married to any team Boston or New England related.
Favorite Holiday: Memorial Day
Favorite Music Album: Way too many and no favorites. I listen to everything.
My Perfect Day: At the beach relaxing or spending time with my family.

Nina Williams

Licensed Title Agent

First Job: Cashier
Favorite Movie: Too many to name
Pets: 4 dogs – Noah, Brandy, Rayna, and Kylo (our working K9)
Favorite compliment: – I remind people of my mother, same work ethic
Something I’m proud of: Getting my title insurance license.
Favorite smell: Yankee Candle – Starfruit and Moonlight
Favorite Holiday: Christmas
Favorite Music Album: No idea, I listen to a little bit of everything.
My Perfect Day: Cruise embarkment day!

Krisi Ferguson

Licensed Title Agent

First Job: Waitress at Quincey at age 15
Favorite Movie: Under the Tuscan Sun and Eat Pray Love
Hidden Talent: Cooking
Pets: Cats (Winston “Win-Win” and Ferguson “Fergie”) Dogs (Dusty and Emmy)
Favorite compliment: That I’m professional yet kind and caring.
Something I’m proud of: My children.
Favorite smell: Homemade apple pie.
Favorite Sports Team: UCF
Favorite Holiday: Thanksgiving
Favorite Music Album: Anything by Aerosmith
My Perfect Day: At the beach relaxing or spending time with my family.

Tammy Duguay

Closing Agent

First Job: Sonny’s BBQ
Favorite Movie: Stepbrothers and Legends of the Fall
Hidden Talent/Hobbies: I am a new crafter at 51 – I have been dabbling in making gifts instead of buying them.
Pets: Dog – Gucci / three turtles
Best compliment I’ve ever received: That my personality sold a customer on using our company.
Introvert or Extrovert: Extrovert – I am a talker
Something I’m Proud of: My children.
Favorite Smell: Fresh cut grass or vanilla
Favorite Sports Team: My favorite teams are the ones my son is on.
Favorite Holiday: Thanksgiving
Favorite Music Album: The Eagles, Chris Stapleton, Gloria Gaynor reminds me of cleaning with my mom when I was growing up. Every Saturday when I heard the “I will survive” song, I knew what time it was!
My Perfect Day: On the boat with my family.

Tina Siau

Title Agent

First Job: Secretary for a private investigator
Favorite Movie: Sweet Home Alabama (1 of them)
Pets: 2 dogs (Mitzy and Mia)
Introvert or Extrovert: Introvert (I guess)
Something I’m Proud of: My children
Favorite Smell: Cinnamon
Favorite Sports Team: I keep up with Clemson Tigers during football season
Favorite Holiday: Christmas
Favorite Music Album: I listen to all different types of music, so I don’t really have a favorite
My Perfect Day: Any day spent hanging out with family and friends

Teresa Roberts

Licensed Title Agent

First Job: Lerner’s in the mall.
Favorite movie: Tropic Thunder
Pets: 2 cats – Marley and Spaz
Favorite Compliment: Most prepared Mom
Something I’m Proud of: My daughter, Morgan.
Favorite Smell: Cinnamon
Favorite Holiday: Halloween
Favorite Music Album: Toys in the Attic
My Perfect Day: No chores lol!

Brian Magley

Signing Agent

First Job: Citrus Farm (135 degree greenhouses)
Favorite Movie: Jaws 1 & 2 (not 3 & 4)
Pets: Batman the French Bulldog
Favorite compliment: “You have beautiful eyes”. Now I’m married to her.
Something I’m proud of: My 9 year old son and his accomplishments in life.
Favorite smell: Fresh cut grass in the rain
Favorite Sports Team: Florida Gators and The Tampa Bay Buccaneers all day, every day. Of course I can’t leave out my sons 8U Pop Warner Viera Hawks Football Team. “GO HAWKS”
Favorite Holiday: It has to be Christmas; although, Thanksgiving is a close second.
Favorite Music Album: My Pandora account on shuffle.
My Perfect Day: Every day above ground is a good day. The perfect day is spent with family and friends and NO DRAMA!!!!

Sarah Long

Title Processor

First Job: Server at Red Lobster
Favorite Movie: The Lost Boys
Hidden Talent: I play flute and piccolo, I love to ski, and I’m not a half bad photographer
Pets: Hazel (dog) and Mya (cat)
Favorite compliment: Whenever someone tells me that Theo (my son) is the best thing ever, which is regularly.
Introvert or Extrovert: I can be both, but I’m more comfortable as as Introvert
Something I’m proud of: My little man, Theo.
Favorite smell: Cinnamon & Clove
Favorite Holiday: Halloween
Favorite Sports Team: KC Chiefs, Kansas Jayhawks, KC Royals
Favorite Music Album: As Daylight Dies – Killswitch Engage
My Perfect Day: A calm snowy day in Breckenridge, CO

Melissa Krupczak

Title Processor

First Job: Cashier/Stock girl @ Best’s Fruit Farm in New Jersey
Favorite Movie: Edward Scissorhands
Hidden Talent: I love crafting any and all things
Pets: 1 silly goose Corgi pup named Willow ❤
Favorite Received Compliment: From my mom when I was in 9th grade – “If I had your strength when I was your age, I would have been unstoppable.”
Introvert or Extrovert: I am a bit of both. I can be reserved at first until I get to know someone 😊
Something I’m Proud of: The accomplishments of those close to my heart!
Favorite Smell: The smell of my Mom & Grandparent’s homes… if comfort was a smell, it’s their homes!
Favorite Holiday: Christmas! Christmas is a close 2nd
Favorite Music Album: Aerosmith Big Ones
My Perfect Day: Sleeping in, snuggling with my hubby and Wi, followed by coffee, running errands with my Gram, Mom or girlfriends OR a Crafternoon with my girl Ann, Carrabba’s Johnny Rocco salad to-go for dinner (chicken parm for my hubby), a glass of wine and a movie night with my Love and Wi ❤

Myanell Enriquez

Title Processor

First Job: Publix Cashier
Favorite Movie: Grease
Pets: 2 Cats – Storn & Nala
Favorite compliment: That I’m very smart.
Something I’m proud of: My children
Favorite smell: Beach/Ocean
Favorite Holiday: Halloween
Favorite Sports Team: Cowboys, FSU, Braves
Favorite Music Album: Menudo
My Perfect Day: By the pool with a drink and a book.

Andrea Hayes

Title Processor

First Job: McDonald’s – Free cheeseburgers
Favorite Movie: Bridesmaids
Hidden Talent: I can play drums
Favorite compliment received: I’m really blunt and authentic
Introvert or Extrovert? Extrovert
Something I’m Proud of: My nieces
Favorite Smell: Cinnabon
Favorite Holiday: time with the family
Favorite Music Album: Eric Church, all of them
My Perfect Day: Pool, drinks, and friends

Amanda McGann

Post Closer

First Job: Server at a Retirement Center
Favorite Movie: I am not really a movie person as though I typically fall asleep during every movie. That being said, I am good watching anything my husband picks.
Pets: I have one dog. An Australian Cattle Dog (Blue Heller) who goes by Bodhi😊
Best compliment I’ve ever received: The best compliment I have ever received is how beautiful my daughter is and that she is beyond perfect😊
Introvert or Extrovert: I am definitely and by far an introvert.
Something I’m proud of: My beautiful spunky little girl Makenna.
Favorite Smell: Fresh brewed coffee, Aspen Woods or the smell of my newborn baby
Favorite Sports Team: Being that I went to the University of Tennessee, when it comes to football I am a huge Tennessee Volunteers fan! V-O-L-S, V-O-L-S, Go Vols, Go! While being born and raised in Cincinnati, Ohio, when it comes to baseball, I am a Cincinnati Reds fan!
Favorite Holiday: That is too hard to pick. I love every holiday because it means I get to spend time with my family. I absolutely love Thanksgiving because I enjoy all the different food. I love Christmas, because I enjoy giving gifts and I also love Fourth of July because I like a nice BBQ on a hot summer day😊
My Perfect Day: My idea of a perfect day is waking up to my baby girl and getting time to snuggle with her while enjoying a cup of coffee followed by taking an adventure/ drive to random locations, whether it be a park, new restaurant or just driving with my husband, little girl and our sweet dog and ending with coming home and spending time together on the couch watching a movie/falling asleep😊

Brendan Rannings

Post Closer

First Job: Host at a restaurant
Favorite Movie: Les Misérables
Hidden Talent: I am a good gamer.
Pets: Kobi, a Siberian Husky
Favorite compliment: I am very caring.
Introvert or Extrovert: An introverted extrovert
Something I’m proud of: I am an Eagle Scout
Favorite smell: My Grandma’s Chicken Parmesan
Favorite Sports Team: I am a big fan of the Patriots, even though they aren’t good anymore.
Favorite Holiday: Christmas
Favorite Music Album: Tommy by The Who
My Perfect Day: Hanging out with my friends and maybe playing some video games, relaxing, or even just sitting outside a camper with my parents and some friends.

Debbie Cassini

Post Closer

First Job: Working at a deli
Hidden Talent/Hobbies: Relaxing either riding with my husband on our motorcycle or floating in the river or pool.
Pets: 3 dogs – Chloe, Zeus, and Lady
Introvert or Extrovert: Introvert
Something I’m Proud of: My children
Favorite Smell: Gardenia
Favorite Sports Team: Football: Alabama/Miami Dolphins
Favorite Holiday: Christmas
My Perfect Day: Spending time with family and friends.

Makayla Halbrook

Post Closer

First Job: A “house cleaner” in the summers during high school. I would go to work with my mom and cleaned homes. It was the worst and I refused to do it after I graduated and got a car.
Favorite Movie: My favorite movie of all time is Tangled.
Hobbies: I really like baking, crafting, and I’m getting back into aquarium keeping.
Pets: I have 2 dogs. One is a Catahoula named Autumn, who’s 15. Then I just adopted a black lab mix named Rona a few months ago. She’s a year and a half and a total terror. I love her to death. Finally, I have a betta fish named Juniper and will be acquiring more fish as I recently got 2 more fish tanks.
Favorite Received Compliment: I’ve been told I’m good at giving gifts.
Introvert or Extrovert: I am most definitely an introvert.
Something I’m proud of: I’m proud of myself and how far I’ve come in the past year.
Favorite Smell: Fresh Laundry or freshly brewed coffee.
Favorite Holiday: I love all holidays, but my ultimate favorite is Christmas! I love giving gifts. It’s so personal and seeing other people light up when they open a present makes me feel so good. Also, I just really like all the pretty lights.
Favorite Music Album: Personally, I think the best music album is Folklore by Taylor Swift. Mostly because I just really love Taylor Swift.
My Perfect Day: The perfect day starts with waking up refreshed and getting to enjoy the morning. The weather to be chilly with a crisp breeze but sunny so that you can feel the sun rays all the way to your toes. I need to spend the day outside and not have to rush around and be somewhere. Just a day to relax and not stress about what I need to be getting done that day.

Michelle Muir

Administrative Assistant

First Job: Babysitting before I could legally work and then a bagger at Gooding’s
Favorite Movie: This is a hard one because I love movies but at the top of the list would be Steel Magnolias because it inspired one of my daughter’s names.
Best compliment I’ve ever received: When my daughter’s tell me I am the best mom ever 😊
Introvert or Extrovert: Extrovert
Something I’m proud of: My two daughter’s Shelby and Riley and my late husband James. Watching him battle cancer for 6 years and fighting for every day he could get with me and our daughters was a true inspiration and I was so proud to be his wife!
Favorite Smell: Fresh baked cookies and coffee
Favorite Sports Team: I am not a big sports fan but I always cheer for Penn State in honor of my late husband James who graduated from Penn State.
Favorite Holiday: Thanksgiving because I love being with my family and of course the food that you only get once a year.
Favorite Music Album: I don’t have a favorite album but love country music.
My Perfect Day: Any day I can spend on vacation with family and/or friends.

Nicki Jenne

Marketing Director

My First Job: Hostess at a Mexican Food Restaurant in Texas. Hellllooo unlimited queso. 😉
Favorite Movie: The Girl Next Door
Hidden talents/hobbies: I grew up dancing and danced professionally in Los Angeles, CA (where I moved from). I also love taking on fixer up projects and making things beautiful again.
Pets: I have a cat with diabetes.
Favorite Compliment: “You’re my person”. The fact that people trust me to be known as “their person” is truly rewarding.
Introvert/Extrovert: Extrovert through and through
Something I’m proud of: My family.
Favorite smell: Black Tie from Bath and Body Works
Favorite sports team: Green Bay Packers. Go Pack Go!
Favorite holiday: Christmas, but also love Thanksgiving and all of the food.
Favorite music album: Justin Timberlake- Future Sex Love Sounds
My perfect day: A day spent with all of my family unplugged from the phone, internet and television. Whether we are at the beach, playing games, or just hanging out.

Elisabeth Herold

Marketing Assistant

First Job: Tropical Smoothie
Favorite Movie: True Romance, 50 First Dates, Mid ‘90s, or Big Fish
Hobbies: The gym and just being active and outside in general, thrifting, and anything artistic like painting or making jewelry. I also have a small collection of old film cameras that I hope to keep growing.
Pets: Two dogs a husky and a Transylvanian hound- Pookah & Daisy
Favorite Compliment: Hearing that I am patient
Introvert or Extrovert: An introverted extrovert
Something I’m proud of: My family, they have all come so far and accomplished so much
Favorite Smell: Jasmine, it smells like home
Favorite Sports Team: Baltimore Ravens
Favorite holiday: Halloween
Favorite music album: Blonde by Frank Ocean, The Divine Feminine by Mac Miller, Melophobia by Cage The Elephant, Purgatory by Tyler Childers, or anything by SZA and Suki Waterhouse. I could name so many more. Ask about my vinyl collection to hear about them.
My perfect day: Doing something active outside with friends and family and then ending it with a beach bonfire